Thread: Nde Q&a
View Single Post
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 10-17-2007, 03:48 AM
Occam's chainsaw Occam's chainsaw is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 76
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eteponge View Post

Got any proof of that? I mean, actual objective evidence which objectively debunks the research findings of multiple medical doctors including Peter Fenwick a respected neuropsychiatrist, Pim Van Lommel a cardiologist, Sam Parnia, Bruce Greyson, Ian Stevenson, Melvin Morse, Michael Sabom, and numerous others, who will tell you the same thing.
Loads - and it has been discussed at length here elsewhere - look around as there is no need to repeat it all here yet again.

Fenwick's reasoning is flawed and he has provided no evidence whatsoever, neither has Parnia (though he is trying to do some nice experiments and I wish him well with those). Van Lommel's article is perhaps the worst I have read in years - nice method but utterly flawed conclusions - Stevenson is not really worth bothering with, Sabom's work has been investigated by others and found wanting.....I could go on.

The best thing to read is independent cognitive neruoscience. You will be amazed.

None of those blogs you cite seem to understand the brain or indeed scientific logic - so their contribution is likely to be unhelpful.
Reply With Quote