Quote:
Originally Posted by David Bailey  I would imagine Alex is busy trying to make his experiment as watertight as possible - just as Rupert Sheldrake did if you actually read his papers. |
I have read the papers and they are by no means as watertight as possible.
I have also read the comments on Alex's opensourcescience and exactly the same criticisms that I have made have been made by "believers". I laso read Alex's reponses where he didn't think some of these controls were necessary. If Alex simply repeats the same type of experiments that Sheldrake has done without making any improvements then he will have achieved absolutely nothing.