Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul C. Anagnostopoulos  What does replaying history have to do with anything?
If you would make the same choice in every universe given the same state of affairs, then your decision is determined by that state of affairs. In what sense is your decision free?
~~ Paul |
I don't know what you mean by "state of affairs". I've said that the physical state of the Universe does not
compel me to behave as I do (although it obviously heavily influences).
So what else? My psychological state? But ones psychological state is partly influenced by ones self. So you would have to say that I am not free because my self dictates what I do. But the self dictating ones actions is precisely what is meant by free will. So your position is absurd.