Quote:
Originally Posted by Open Mind  The protocol is fine ... however if for Richard Wiseman to conduct he has already pretty much done that (along with Ciaran O'Keeffe) . They used 5 mediums otherwise the protocol is very similar.
The result ..... the mediums failed. |
cause he used shitty mediums. Obviously we couldn't let Wiseman pick the medium to be tested but everything else about the experiment could be done by him.
Quote:
|
I reckon the quality of mediums chosen are the most critical factor
|
definately
Quote:
|
Perhaps we shouldn't expect sciences of the mind like psychology, parapsychology, etc. to produce the same endlessly replicable results as in the physical sciences like physics, chemistry etc. (Assuming these are, the experiments are seldom blind) Medicine is in trouble if we demand success in short trials.
|
only a repeatable experiment can establish Psi. I have an overall positive view of Psi but I won't be convinced until we have a phenomena that can be demonstrated on demand.