View Single Post
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 07-24-2008, 04:50 AM
David Bailey David Bailey is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 1,036
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Venom View Post
Anyway, does it even occur to those psi-believers that saying that if consciousness exist outside of the brain, we should be able to observe consciousness in that state (and not by testimonies of any sort, I'm talking about direct observation). Or do they claim that consciousness just exist outside our reality, in a supernatural world. If they do that, do they realise that they just left the realm of science and enter the realm of... I don't know... religion?

I mean, if supernature exist, can we observe it directly? And can we explain the process that occurs in it? I don't think so (well, because I don't think that a supernature do exist anyway).
Now there is a proposal - how do you reckon we could tackle that? I mean, it could be that such detection is impossible, but suppose we take the idea half seriously - perhaps trying to study various physical processes in close proximity to a head as compared to further away. Maybe such a study would delineate a region round the body roughly in the shape of an aura!

Would you like to do such a study and try to publish it - particularly if you found an effect! My point is that your proposal might be feasible, but there is absolutely no serious effort being directed to finding out.

David
Reply With Quote